The two vocalists here are coincidentally the two members with the most solo material as well, Riyu & Noria. Their voices work pretty well as a duet because they're so different from each other. You can appreciate both voices for different reasons in this song. I love it, I wish they had more material with 2 people.

The LIVE BAND style version has good music to it, too - I love BeForU with guitars and such. It takes a cute song and puts a rock twist on it.

My only real complaint with ☆shining☆ is that I think Riyu gets more than Noria (either that or her singing just drowns her out, either way), and I would have liked a slightly more even mix. But I really can't complain much because the song turned out great.

☆shining☆ is different enough to be a nice change, but still has that BeForU sound. For a different twist and a fun song, ☆shining☆ is great!